TooJay’s Menu With Prices For 2026
Comfort food takes center stage on the TooJay’s Menu, with a variety of deli-style favorites, sandwiches, soups, salads, breakfast dishes, and traditional entrées. The menu reflects the classic New York deli experience while offering plenty of choices for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
From stacked sandwiches and savory soups to hearty platters and freshly prepared salads, there are options for different appetites throughout the day. You can also find bakery treats and desserts when you want something sweet after your meal.
Checking the TooJay’s Menu ahead of time gives you a better idea of what to expect before visiting. This guide covers popular sandwiches, breakfast items, soups, salads, entrées, sides, desserts, and other choices that may be worth trying.
TooJay’s Menu With Prices
A TooJay’s Menu With Prices helps you explore popular New York-style deli dishes before visiting the restaurant or placing an online order. It makes comparing sandwiches, soups, salads, and breakfast much easier while helping you plan your budget and calorie intake. From the classic Reuben to matzo ball soup, this printable menu gives you a convenient overview of TooJay’s most popular selections.
Sandwiches
Sandwiches are the heart of the TooJay’s menu, built around classic New York deli traditions with generous portions of premium sliced meats. Every sandwich comes with a choice of side, typically coleslaw and a dill pickle, rounding out the meal without needing extra additions.
The Reuben, piled high with corned beef, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese grilled on rye with Russian dressing, remains the single most requested item on the entire menu. The Combo, which layers corned beef, roast beef, turkey, and Swiss cheese rolled with coleslaw and homestyle Russian dressing, gives guests a way to sample multiple meats in one order.
A plant-based grilled patty, served on a brioche bun with crisp lettuce and fresh tomatoes, gives vegetarian guests a hearty option within the same sandwich format. The Deli Sampler, which includes any three sliced deli meats over lettuce with coleslaw, potato salad, and rye bread, is popular for guests who want variety without committing to a single sandwich build.
Because portions run generous across this category, many guests find that a single sandwich, paired with the included sides, is more than enough for a full meal, making the sandwich section one of the best overall values on the menu.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Reuben | $14.99 | 1,100 cal |
| The Combo | $15.49 | 1,050 cal |
| Plant-Based Grilled Patty | $13.99 | 1,380 cal |
| Deli Sampler | $16.99 | 740–1,070 cal |
Soups & Starters
Soups and starters give guests a lighter, more traditional way to begin their meal, leaning heavily on classic deli comfort food. This category is especially popular during colder months, when a warm bowl of soup pairs naturally with a smaller sandwich.
Matzo ball soup is the signature starter at TooJay’s, and it’s frequently cited as one of the main reasons regulars keep returning. The chain’s rotating daily soup special gives guests something new to try on repeat visits, while French onion soup, topped with a thick layer of provolone and Parmesan, offers a heartier, cheesier alternative.
Fried dill pickle chips, lightly battered and served with creamy horseradish sauce, are a popular starter for guests who want something crispier before their entrée arrives. Because soups and starters are priced lower than the full sandwiches, many guests pair a cup of soup with a smaller salad rather than ordering a single large item.
This category also works well for guests visiting specifically for a lighter lunch, since a bowl of soup alongside a side salad can make a complete, satisfying meal without the heavier calorie count of a full sandwich.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Matzo Ball Soup | $6.99 | 60–230 cal |
| French Onion Soup | $7.49 | 220 cal |
| Spicy Soup Special | $6.99 | 220–260 cal |
| Fried Dill Pickle Chips | $8.99 | 630 cal |
Salads
Salads at TooJay’s give guests a fresher, lighter alternative to the heavier sandwiches and deli classics elsewhere on the menu. This category has grown in recent years as the restaurant has expanded its lighter, vegetable-forward options.
A fresh tomato and cucumber salad, tossed with red onion and Italian vinaigrette, is one of the lightest options on the entire menu and works well as a side or a starter. Roasted Brussels sprouts and seasonal vegetables, topped with crispy bacon and a balsamic glaze, give guests a heartier vegetable-based option, with a vegetarian version available without the bacon.
Protein-topped salads, built around sliced turkey or roast beef, give guests a way to enjoy a lighter meal without sacrificing the deli flavors the restaurant is known for. Because salads are priced lower than most sandwiches, this category is a popular choice for guests watching their calorie intake or looking for a smaller midday meal.
Dressings are made in-house, consistent with the from-scratch approach found throughout the rest of the TooJay’s menu, giving even the lighter salads the same signature deli flavor.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Tomato & Cucumber Salad | $7.99 | 80 cal |
| Roasted Brussels Sprouts | $8.99 | 480–500 cal |
| Turkey Chef Salad | $14.49 | 620 cal |
Breakfast
Breakfast at TooJay’s leans on classic deli-style morning dishes, giving guests a hearty start to the day built around eggs, bagels, and the same premium sliced meats used throughout the rest of the menu. This category is popular with regulars who visit specifically for a weekend brunch.
Crispy mini potato pancakes topped with smoked salmon, sour cream, arugula, and capers are a signature breakfast item that leans into the deli’s New York roots. Blintzes, filled with either potato or spinach, give guests a savory alternative to the sweeter breakfast classics elsewhere on the menu.
A crunchy sampling of scratch-made pancakes served with sour cream is a popular choice for guests who want something a bit different from a standard stack. Homemade bagels, along with muffins and Danish pastries, round out the lighter breakfast options for guests who want something quicker.
Because breakfast at TooJay’s tends to be more elaborate than a typical fast-casual option, many guests treat it as a full sit-down meal rather than a quick grab-and-go stop.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Smoked Salmon Potato Pancakes | $13.49 | 670 cal |
| Potato or Spinach Blintzes | $11.99 | 350–360 cal |
| Homemade Bagel with Cream Cheese | $5.49 | 420 cal |
Desserts
Desserts round out the TooJay’s menu with classic bakery-style treats made fresh in-house daily. This category has become just as much a draw as the sandwiches for guests who specifically visit for something sweet.
The banana dream cake is the signature dessert on the menu, frequently mentioned by name in reviews and recommendations from regulars. Classic cheesecake and a rotating selection of pies round out the bakery case for guests who want a more traditional dessert option.
Because desserts are made from scratch, portion sizes tend to run generous, and many guests choose to split a single slice between two people rather than ordering individual desserts. Coffee and specialty drinks pair naturally with the bakery items, rounding out the classic deli dining experience.
Seasonal dessert specials also rotate throughout the year, giving regulars a reason to check back for something new beyond the year-round banana dream cake and cheesecake offerings.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Banana Dream Cake | $7.99 | 720 cal |
| Classic Cheesecake | $7.49 | 640 cal |
| Slice of Pie | $6.99 | 480–550 cal |
Tips For Ordering At TooJay’s
Because sandwich portions run generous, splitting a Reuben or Combo between two guests is a practical way to sample the signature deli flavors without over-ordering, especially when paired with a cup of matzo ball soup or a side salad. Visiting during a weekday lunch rather than a weekend brunch can also mean shorter waits, since TooJay’s tends to draw a busy crowd for breakfast and brunch service.
Checking your local TooJay’s for daily soup specials is worth doing before you order, since the rotating soup selection changes regularly and isn’t always listed on the standard printed menu. For guests watching calories, pairing a lighter salad with a cup of soup rather than a full sandwich is an easy way to enjoy the menu while keeping the overall meal lighter.
If you’re visiting specifically for dessert, calling ahead to confirm your local bakery case has the banana dream cake in stock is a good idea, since it’s one of the most popular items and can sell out during busier periods.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where Can You Find A TooJay’s Menu With Prices?
You can find a TooJay’s Menu With Prices by visiting the official TooJay’s website, where current pricing for sandwiches, soups, and salads is typically listed. Some locations may also have printed menus available in-store.
Printing the menu ahead of time helps you compare sandwiches, soups, and breakfast items at your own pace, which is especially useful when planning a group lunch or weekend brunch.
Does A TooJay’s Menu With Prices Include Calories?
Yes, a TooJay’s Menu With Prices typically includes calorie information alongside pricing for most menu items, helping guests compare nutritional content before ordering. Exact calorie counts can vary depending on preparation and portion size.
For guests with specific dietary needs, checking with your local restaurant directly is recommended for the most accurate calorie information.
Why Do Prices On A TooJay’s Menu Change?
Menu prices can vary because of differences in restaurant location and local operating costs. A TooJay’s Menu With Prices gives you a helpful estimate, but your nearest location may charge slightly more or less.
Confirming current pricing on the official website before ordering, especially for larger combo plates, helps you avoid any surprises when the bill arrives.
Can You Use A TooJay’s Menu With Prices To Plan A Group Order?
Yes, a TooJay’s Menu With Prices makes group planning much easier. You can compare the cost of individual sandwiches against combo plates and deli samplers to determine which option gives your group the best value.
Reviewing the menu in advance also helps you decide on soups and salads ahead of time, which speeds up ordering once your group has been seated.
Does TooJay’s Offer Vegetarian Options?
Yes, TooJay’s offers a variety of vegetarian options, including a plant-based grilled patty, several salads, and breakfast items like blintzes. It’s a good idea to ask about specific preparation methods if you have dietary restrictions.
Checking the printable menu in advance allows vegetarian guests to plan their order around available options without needing to ask extensive questions once seated.
Final Word
A TooJay’s Menu With Prices makes it much easier to plan your meal before visiting the restaurant or placing an online order. From the classic Reuben and matzo ball soup to fresh salads and the signature banana dream cake, having a printable menu helps you compare prices, check calories, and choose meals that fit your budget and appetite.
Keeping a TooJay’s Menu With Prices on hand also saves time when planning a weekday lunch, weekend brunch, or a group gathering. Since menu items, prices, and calorie counts may vary by location and change over time, checking the latest printable version before ordering is always a smart choice. With the right menu in hand, you can enjoy TooJay’s classic deli flavors while making informed dining decisions.